Roll Back my Thunderfury

If you have the item, Ikutaba, the criteria would be met once the achievement is implemented. It is based on an item, not an action.

It should also be noted that if you wish to see a change made to the game, even to something that isn't even close to release yet, you'll want to post in the Suggestion forum.

Q u o t e:
Latest post from GC on the beta forums would contradict that.

But arguing over beta stuff is like arguing over next weeks weather, amusing but ultimately fruitless.

Hmm, I haven't seen that one. The last reply I could see by Ghostcrawler is one on the Holy Paladin tree. Though you are correct, everything is subject to change, especially while it is still in beta.

How I described it should be how it works based on my experience with the current achievements out there. Much like if you possessed a Blue Brewfest Stein when the achievement system was released you would automatically receive the achievement: Blue Brewfest Stein - currently under Feat of Strength.

Q u o t e:
Just for clarification, is this a one time application? Say I were to form a guild in Cataclysm, and a bunch of us have legendaries. Does it apply to that guild? Or does it only apply to the guild I am in once the 4.0 patch is applied?

You are asking for details on an achievement and system that is still in beta, Ikutaba. I, as a non-developer wouldn't have any idea at this point.

Post in the Cataclysm Beta forum.

Q u o t e:


But I can't, I don't have one of those nifty beta invite thingies :(

Then try the normal Cataclysm forum. :)

http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/board.html?sid=1&forumId=78416

Q u o t e:
New post over here \o/

http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=26560866316&sid=1

That's this thread, Ikutaba. O.o