#3 - July 23, 2010, 6:52 a.m.
Just an update, you'll likely receive the news through an in-game mail but from what I see of the encounter, Nobank, the other person won the item fair and square. They rolled a 86, which would beat your 76.
If I had fully understood the issue at hand. It seems your issue is that someone was able to receive the Battered Hilt even though you believed you won.
I am sorry that you were unable to receive the item this time around but I wish you well in getting it next time.