While the wiki is great and all for info on the game I’ve been noticing formatting inconsistencies, flow issues, and content organizational problems. Here are some examples:
Similar pages should be formatted identically. And objects such as the TOC and images need to flow naturally with the contents of the article. See this page (http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Chef) for example. The images and TOC combined, form a flow issue leaving a big empty space in the middle of the beginning of the page. And is also inconsistent with the designs of similar pages (the other craft discipline pages) which float the TOC right. Which is designed to allow the article to flow around the TOC. Proper formatting in pages like this would be to have the text flow around the images either on the left, right or top of the images and have the TOC float to the right of all that.
Also there is the flow issues as seen in this page (http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Artificer) the TOC is floated to the right as is best for not having to scroll past the TOC to get to the article content however a side effect occurs when the article has a table in and there is insufficient text preceding the table to push the table below the TOC. As a result there is a big gap of blank space between the text and the table associated with the text. The TOCright template has parameters one of which seems to be the solution. But isn’t as far as I have tried to use them to correct the flow problem.
Now take the articles for each dungeon. You can get the links to them from this page (http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Dungeon). Each dungeon’s page the TOC is inconsistently placed or absent. The use of headings is over done in some of them. But at least is consistent in one regard: the main TOC headings. But again these pages share the same flow problems the other examples show. big blank areas where text should flow around. Also the chart at the bottom of each dungeon’s page links to separate pages for story mode and explorable mode. These separate pages are not needed. The one page for each dungeon with the same major heading order is the proper way to go. Since the Caudecus’s Manor page is the only one not currently filled with content I edited it to use as an example for how to do these pages. http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Caudecus%27s_Manor
I haven’t done dungeons yet so I can’t contribute to the details in the pages. But a good start is with what info we already have in the articles. Anyone willing to flesh out and provide more details where needed please help contribute to them.
